1: Dan Deacon: Bromst
Most artists can’t manage in one album what Dan Deacon does in one song. His compositions are laced with references to greats Philip Glass and John Cage, while also referencing popular hip hop, ranges of pop music, sometimes blues, sometimes jazz, a host of unprecedented sonic intricacies, all while maintaining the innocent colorings of morning cartoons. With Bromst, Deacon changed directions and took on, in appropriate amounts, adult concerns. His first album Spiderman of the Rings may have very briefly touched on the damage mankind does to the world, but it never gave up its childishness. On Bromst cut “Snookered,” Deacon sings with rare clarity and self-awareness, “This taste of milk is almost gone, still got my shape but not for long / Been wrong so many times before, but never quite like this….” As if to further annunciate his feelings, he includes in a massively delayed and effected, acapela Southern funeral dirge “Wet Wings.” But sooner or later each of these songs sores with amazing imagination and chaotic, youthful abandon that we expect from the Acorn Master. At such an early point in his career, Deacon seems to already have mastered his medium and we are left to wonder in what ways he will amaze next.
2: Grizzly Bear: Veckatimest
There is no denying Veckatimest was a departure from the wooden depths of Yellow House to a more dynamic — and shinier — pop. Of course what Veckatimest lacks in natural depth (“lack” is only a relative term when comparing any output to Yellow House) it makes up for in bolder, louder, and more intricate expressions. The band has taken over indie pop with well-crafted and sometimes strange tunes, but it’s timing so far has been perfect, which is just a shade better than this album.
3: Animal Collective: Merriweather Post Pavillion
MPP is home to some of the catchiest and well crafted pop songs Animal Collective has ever made, and because of that, along with steadily mounting attention and popularity over the last few years, this is the most popular AC album yet. While everyone can argue whether or not any of this should be the case, whether or not this album actually is any better than previous ones or just the result of wild popularity, the fact remains that with quality song after experimental but accessible quality song, MPP is indeed an instant classic and it deserves to be recognized as one of the best albums of 2009. AC have already shown signs of further evolution with newest release Fall Be Kind (honorable mention), which goes to show Animal Collective just may be able to do anything they put their minds to.
4: Dirty Projectors: Bitte Orca
The first few listens of this recording left me disappointed. But when I watched the band perform the better half of this album live, my faith was renewed and my backsliding had ended. Not only are DP one of the most successfully experimental pop groups around, they’re possibly the most talented live performers, too.
5: A Sunny Day in Glasgow: Ashes Grammar
I had high hopes for this album after 2007’s Scribble Mural Comic Journal, and this 23 track LP more than made my high hopes look like silly, little expectations. Someone sold their soul to the devil. It’s packed with gems such as “Failure,” “Close Chorus,” “Shy,” and the excellent back to back songs “Ashes Grammar” – “Ashes Math.” This album would have been very comfortable in the number two spot.
6: Memory Tapes: Seek Magic
Anything that mimics Aphex Twin so well gets an A from me, but Memory Tape’s release exhibits a life in an electronic world all its own. With myriad landscapes and double take inducing samples, this is easily one of the best electronic works of 2009.
7: Fever Ray: Fever Ray
A fan of The Knife from the first time I heard Heartbeats, I wasn’t sure what to expect from this solo album, yet Fever Ray carries almost all the strange soul of The Knife with an added eeriness no one thought possible.
8: Atlas Sound: Logos
A disappointement from Bradford Cox is still my 8th best album of the year. Cox continues to carry the brightest torches: ambient, garage, shoegaze, avant-pop, techno – they’re all here, even if a few brief moments are hit or miss.
9: Tune-Yards: Bird Brain
Tune-Yards has the looping ability of Andrew Bird and Final Fantasy with a little extra X factor: pop sensibilities that make each of these songs stick to listeners’ brains like the strongest transparent adhesive.
10: St. Vincent: Actor
Simply fantastic
11: Themselves: CrownsDown
I can’t say how happy I am that Doseone re-emerged this year with another Themselves album. Still one of the most frighteningly linguistic and thoughtful rappers around, Doseone pounds another nail in with this one.
12: Tiny Vipers: Life on Earth
“Tiny Vipers (Seattleite Jesy Fortino) makes the type of music that you don’t want to clap for after hearing it performed live for fear of breaking what’s left in the echoing air.”
13: Le Loup: Family
Copycats? Sure. But Le Loup take what they’ve learned from this year’s top three album artists, Dan Deacon, Animal Collective, and Grizzly Bear, and make a sound all their own.
14: Beirut/Real People: March of the Zapotec/Holland
There was little impressive about Beirut’s 2007’s Flying Club Cup, but March of the Zapotec feels like a worthy trip with artist Zach Condon down to southern Mexico, and the young musician’s complete abilities came through loud and clear when he turned off all those brass horns for addictive electronic compositions of Holland. Condon is a prodigious songwriter, and if this “double ep” is any indication, he’ll keep finding new ways to express himself.
YACHT: See Mystery Lights
This group seems to be one big collection of ridiculousness, which is why it took me a couple of months to finally push play on any of their songs, but after listening to See Mystery Lights and watching videos of their live performances, I have to consider YACHT one of the biggest pleasant surprises of 2009. Even the greatest critical acclaim couldn’t do what a simple minute of boredom and curiosity could.
16: Volcano Choir: Unmap
Folk-man Justin Vernon may have met his match in electronic outfit Collections of Colonies of Bees. Though this album could have done a little more with its time, the result of the Wisconsin-ites collaboration is gold.